The Bitter Honey Project

Nonnie cookies—and the deodorant cap she couldn’t throw away

The secret story behind my Calabrian Nonnie’s sugar cookies

Jump to Shawna’s recipe
Nonnie, in a pink blouse and floral skirt, sitting in a gold velvet armchair beside young Shawna in a blue T-shirt.
Nonnie and IPhoto by Shawna Ferrato

Mary Viola (my father’s mother, my Nonnie) was the oldest girl of twelve children born to Italian parents who emigrated from Acri, Cosenza, Calabria to New Jersey. Nonnie never went past eighth grade—being the oldest girl, she put caring for her family first. But her love, wisdom, and green thumb live on in all of us.

Nonnie relaxing in a woven lawn chair in front of a leafy hedge.
NonniePhoto by Shawna Ferrato

And so do her cookies!

Nonnie’s cookies were thin, crisp sugar cookies, shaped as stars, hearts, and a unique oblong. She stored the tin—one of those blue Danish cookie tins that everyone keeps their sewing kit in—in a closet somewhere. Whether we were visiting her, or she was visiting us, her cookies were always a family favorite.

When I visited her after school, she would serve me a cup of tea with some of her cookies. The oblong shape was my favorite—it was perfect for dunking. It was only years later, when I was baking with her as an adult, that I recognized the cutter that she used to give those cookies their shape.

It was the cap of a stick of deodorant!

You might think, “Ew Deodorant?!” But I could only laugh, and smile, and say “Non!” She was so resourceful. Like most people who grew up during the Great Depression, Nonnie saved EVERYTHING. Nothing went to waste, not even the cap of a stick of deodorant.

I begged her to write this recipe down for me in the 1990s, and it’s the only recipe I have of hers.

As she wrote it in her careful handwriting, the recipe calls for margarine—margarine was a big fad in the 1990s. But I know she used butter before then, and I recommend you do too.

Nonnie’s handwritten recipe for Old Fashion Sugar Cookies on lined notebook paper.
Nonnie’s recipe, in her handwritingPhoto by Shawna Ferrato

She never told me how far back this recipe goes in her family, but every time I eat one of those cookies it warms my heart—the same way Nonnie always did.

Get Bitter Honey recipes and stories in your inbox.

Bitter Honey will always be free for everyone. —Giuditta

Recipe: Old-fashioned sugar cookies (Nonnie cookies)

Makes about 3 dozen cookies · Prep 20 min · Cook 8 min · Dessert · Italian American

A plate of homemade star-shaped and round Nonnie cookies.
Nonnie cookiesPhoto by Shawna Ferrato

Ingredients

  • ½ teaspoon vanilla
  • ½ cup sugar
  • ⅓ teaspoon baking soda
  • ½ teaspoon baking powder
  • 1 tablespoon milk
  • 1 egg
  • ¼ pound margarine (soft, room temp)
  • 2 cups flour (any brand)

Method

  1. Margarine must be room temp. (soft)
  2. Preheat oven (400 degrees).
  3. Grease cookie sheets before you lay cookies on them.
  4. Mix in plastic bowl with fork (vanilla, margarine, baking soda, baking powder, milk, egg, sugar), then add 1 cup flour.
  5. Add second cup flour gradually. If too dry add a little milk.
  6. Use hands to mix & work dough together, then take ¼ of the dough at a time and roll out on floured board.
  7. Use cookie cutters & shape & lay on greased cookie sheets.
  8. Cookies bake in 6 to 8 min.

My recommendation: use ¼ pound (1 stick) of softened butter instead.

All photos courtesy of Shawna.

Others remember

What people said after reading Shawna’s story

I love Shawna❤️ and remember so well the favorite cookies that we all enjoyed. Mary would bring them to the voting place where she volunteered and shared her cookies with everyone there. My boys relished every bite. Wonderful tribute ❤️

Does Shawna’s story bring back a memory of your own family? I’d love to hear about it!— Giuditta

Places in this story

Acri · CalabriaA Calabrian hill town in the province of Cosenza known for its olives, chestnuts, and salumi.

The Bitter Honey Project

The recipes the women and men of the Italian diaspora carried across the water, and the stories behind them.

Bitter Honey stories are collected by Giuditta Pileri.

Recent posts

My mother’s fennel taralli, sealed with a key Craco never left us Joe Rinaldi · Craco · Toronto Potatoes and eggs—our go-to for four generations Don’t know what to make? Make this! Shawna Ferrato · Campobasso · Wayne, NJ

Get Bitter Honey recipes and stories in your inbox.

Bitter Honey will always be free for everyone. —Giuditta

Share this post