The Bitter Honey Project

Potatoes and eggs—our go-to for four generations

Don’t know what to make? Make this!

Jump to Shawna’s recipe
Hand-tinted studio portrait of Shawna’s grandmother Dolores as a young woman, smiling, with waved dark hair and a pendant necklace.
My grandmother DoloresPhoto by Shawna Ferrato

When I asked my mom which dish takes her back, she said, “potatoes and eggs.”

Her mother, my grandmother Dolores, made it for her. She learned it from her mother, my great-grandmother Filomena—Minnie to the family. Filomena was one of the oldest of a very large Italian family that immigrated through Ellis Island. Her husband, Gabriel Fuschillo, was born in Naples and came here much later. He was a truck driver in Jersey City.

Pastel drawing of Filomena, an elderly woman with white hair and large glasses, in a polka-dot blouse against a green background.
My great-grandmother FilomenaPhoto by Shawna Ferrato

I learned the recipe from my mother, who learned it from her mother, and so on. Eggs were popular in that family.

My mom can whip up an amazing meal with whatever she has. She never uses a recipe, and always does something a little different to make it hers. Even though she worked full time, our dinners were always family style: a protein, some starch, and multiple vegetables on platters on the table. We plated our food ourselves. Each night was a feast. We always finished with a simple salad of romaine, chicory, cucumbers and tomatoes (salad last, for digestion). I wasn’t allowed to leave the table until everyone was finished eating.

But on nights when she didn’t have much time to make a meal, it was potatoes and eggs. Low on ingredients? Potatoes and eggs! Not sure what to make? Potatoes and eggs! Get home late and short on time? Potatoes and eggs! Feeling melancholy? Potatoes and eggs! You get the point.

I know some Italians enjoy their late-night pasta. My mom made potatoes and eggs.

Sepia snapshot of two young girls in dresses on a city sidewalk, with a small white dog perched on a wrought-iron chair beside them.
My grandmother Dolores (the taller one) and her sister Marie, in Jersey CityPhoto by Shawna Ferrato

Dolores ate very slowly, and relished every bite. Eating for her was an experience and a ritual. She took pride in her food.

It’s not quite a frittata, just potatoes and eggs, with parsley and pecorino. I’m not sure if it’s Italian, or Italian American—maybe both. Here in New Jersey, you can get something similar as a sandwich in most Italian delis and salumerias that serve hot food. I’ve even had potato and egg pizza.

I make potatoes and eggs when I’m craving something warm and delicious but not in the mood to cook a full meal—like pastina and eggs when you aren’t feeling well.

I asked my mother for the recipe, and of course she didn’t give it to me. I had to figure it out from the way I make it. Family is so funny with writing down recipes.

Shawna’s handwritten recipe for Italian Potatoes and Eggs in blue ink on a lined notepad page.
The recipe, in my handwritingPhoto by Shawna Ferrato

When I smell potatoes and eggs cooking, it reminds me of the four generations of girls, all of us at one time together in the kitchen. A big argument, I’m sure. Ha!

Sometimes it’s these simple dishes, done right, that take us back in time through the generations.

P.S. I drew the picture of Filomena. She got a little crazy and angrier as she got older, so it’s a funny depiction of her.

Get Bitter Honey recipes and stories in your inbox.

Bitter Honey will always be free for everyone. —Giuditta

Recipe: Italian potatoes and eggs (frittata di patate)

Serves 4 · Prep 25 min · Cook 20 min · Main course · Molisan, Italian

A wedge of golden potato and egg frittata on a blue-and-white plate, with broccoli and a bowl of salad.
My potatoes and eggs (I might have snuck some mushrooms in)Photo by Shawna Ferrato

Ingredients

  • 2–3 potatoes (whatever you have in the house), cooked in boiling salted water until tender, drained and cooled, then sliced
  • 6–8 eggs (depending on how many you’re feeding)
  • fresh ground pepper
  • sea salt
  • 2 tbsp extra virgin olive oil
  • 2–3 tbsp pecorino romano, grated
  • parsley, chopped

Method

  1. Heat the oil in a pan and crisp the potato, add some salt. Cook until golden brown.
  2. Beat eggs with cheese and pour over potatoes. Add more olive oil as needed.
  3. When cooked on one side, flip it. It’s easier if you slide it out of the pan onto a plate, cooked side down. Turn the pan upside down over the plate, then flip it back over.
  4. Cook the other side until golden brown.
  5. Sprinkle with parsley and fresh pepper to taste. Cut and serve while hot.

All photos courtesy of Shawna.

Others remember

What people said after reading Shawna’s story

I was planning on making this tomorrow! It was comfort food for my mother and I make it on the anniversary of her passing.

Does Shawna’s story bring back a memory of your own family? I’d love to hear about it!— Giuditta

Places in this story

Campobasso · MoliseCampobasso, the capital of Molise, is known for its knife-making tradition and the annual Misteri procession during Corpus Domini.

The Bitter Honey Project

The recipes the women and men of the Italian diaspora carried across the water, and the stories behind them.

Bitter Honey stories are collected by Giuditta Pileri.

Recent posts

My mother’s fennel taralli, sealed with a key Craco never left us Joe Rinaldi · Craco · Toronto Nonnie cookies—and the deodorant cap she couldn’t throw away The secret story behind my Calabrian Nonnie’s sugar cookies Shawna Ferrato · New Jersey · Acri

Get Bitter Honey recipes and stories in your inbox.

Bitter Honey will always be free for everyone. —Giuditta

Share this post